collective unconscious, term introduced by psychiatrist Carl Jung to represent a form of the unconscious (that part of the mind containing memories and impulses of which the individual is not aware) common to mankind as a whole and originating in the inherited structure of the brain. [9] He credited Freud for developing his "primal horde" theory in Totem and Taboo and continued further with the idea of an archaic ancestor maintaining its influence in the minds of present-day humans. Ultimately, although Jung referred to the collective unconscious as an empirical concept, based on evidence, its elusive nature does create a barrier to traditional experimental research. According to Jung, the ego represents the conscious mind as it comprises the thoughts, memories, and emotions a person is aware of. The theory of the collective unconscious is based on archetypes. [27] These archetypes, a special focus of Jung's work, become autonomous personalities within an individual psyche. Using data from the Archive for Research in Archetypal Symbolism and a jury of evaluators, Rosen et al. However, in modern Western civilization men are discouraged from living their feminine side and women from expressing masculine tendencies. "Synchronicity and the Archetypes,". Therefore, argues Jung, Freudian psychoanalysis would neglect important sources for unconscious ideas, in the case of a patient with neurosis around a dual-mother image. (for more on screen writing and Joseph Campbell, see Christopher Voglers The Writers Journey: Mythic Structure For Writers). When an artist has a figure from the collective unconscious, he at once begins to play with it esthetically, and usually makes some concretization of it as a monument, etc. [25], A more common experimental approach investigates the unique effects of archetypal images. The circular shape of the flying saucer confirms its symbolic connection to repressed but psychically necessary ideas of divinity. Some cultures may split this archetype up; so the womb may express itself as Mary, Mother of Christ (or more recently via Dan Brown as Mary Magdaline, bride of Christ), or in devouring images as seen in depictions of females as vampires, succubi or witches (not to be confused with Wiccans). It is the present and the future, which in his view was the key to both the analysis of neurosis and its treatment. collective unconscious, term introduced by psychiatrist Carl Jung to represent a form of the unconscious (that part of the mind containing memories and impulses of which the individual is not aware) common to mankind as a whole and originating in the inherited structure of the brain. The names will change, but the song remains the same. The personal unconscious consists of everything subliminal, forgotten, and repressed in an individual's life. The three main ones were the ego, the personal unconscious, and the collective unconscious. These ancestral memories, which Jung called Carl jung. He also identified four basic functions (thinking, feeling, sensing, and intuiting) which in a cross-classification yield eight pure personality types. On The Relation Of Analytical Psychology To Poetic Art 1. Abstract. Are archetypes transmitted more by culture than biology? )[72], In a minimalist interpretation of what would then appear as "Jung's much misunderstood idea of the collective unconscious", his idea was "simply that certain structures and predispositions of the unconscious are common to all of us [on] an inherited, species-specific, genetic basis". [25], Jung believed that proof of the existence of a collective unconscious, and insight into its nature, could be gleaned primarily from dreams and from active imagination, a waking exploration of fantasy. The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious, 9(Part 1), 207-254. Jung, C. G. (1947). I take a hybrid approach: in so much as there some universals for all human beings, there should be some universality to our stories. [50][51] Understanding the power of the collective unconscious can help an individual to navigate through life. Variant Myths Versions of the same myth found in the same culture Hubris Excessive pride Pantheon 244.] [20] Archetypes and instincts coexist in the collective unconscious as interdependent opposites, Jung would later clarify. It consists of 6 . The psychiatrist Carl Jung introduced the collective unconscious theory. Thats where a model based on dispersion makes sense. Log In Sign Up Username . Because all people have families, encounter plants and animals, and experience night and day, it should come as no surprise that they develop basic mental structures around these phenomena. 2022;3:100033. doi:10.1016/j.diggeo.2022.100033, Cacha L, Poznanski R. Genomic instantiation of consciousness in neurons through a biophoton field theory. The entirety of the collective unconscious is God. Psychology and alchemy. The phenomenology of the spirit in fairy tales. He argued that the collective unconscious had a profound influence on the lives of individuals, who lived out its symbols and clothed them in meaning through their experiences. Jung even referred to it as a, "psychic . [2] Critics of the collective unconscious concept have called it unscientific and fatalistic, or otherwise very difficult to test scientifically (due to the mystical aspect of the collective unconscious). The persona (or mask) is the outward face we present to the world. It was also what separated him from the theories and ultimately friendship - of Sigmund Freud. It is composed of archetypes, which are simple. The Romans openly took their religions from the Greeks. [31] In alchemy, Jung found that plain water, or seawater, corresponded to his concept of the collective unconscious.[32]. It is generally associated with idealism and was coined by Carl Jung. Int J Jungian Studies. Dreams were thought to provide key insight into the collective unconscious. More than just being repressed wishes, Jung felt that dreams compensate for parts of the psyche that are underdeveloped in our waking lives. Collective Unconscious The theory is that there are thoughts that are ingrained in every human from birth. And of course, some of us move. and work in solidarity with oppressed groups in the . He got into his neurosis through the . The psyche of a woman contains masculine aspects (the animus archetype), and the psyche of a man contains feminine aspects (the anima archetype). Questions arising from conceptualizations of the archetype, Struggling with jung: The value of uncertainty, Listen to a BBC radio broadcast on Carl Jung. And what do we take with us? This is because it is difficult to scientifically prove that images of mythology and other cultural symbols are inherited and present at birth. Young-Eisendrath, P. (1995). The theor proposed by: American Psychological Association. For instance, a 2015 study suggests that the gut microbiome may play a role in how the unconscious regulates behavior. Thus, Jung's ideas continue to be assessed to better understand the collective unconscious and how it works. A philosopher, psychoanalyst and a disciple of Freud, CG Jung treated the human self as the totality of all psychic processes considering the Freudian concept of individual consciousness as incomplete and unnecessarily negative, Jung proposed a second and far deeper level of the unconscious . praecox, there is disease. The preference for distinct contrasts is hypothesized to . According to Jung, the collective unconscious contains archetypes, or universal primordial images and ideas. It differs from our personal psyches and complexes that are developed individually. This chapter provides an overview of the seminal works on collective consciousness in sociology. Even a simple hungry feeling can lead to many different responses, including metaphorical sublimation. Freud, on the other hand, often suggested that specific symbols represent specific unconscious thoughts. In line with evolutionary theory it may be that Jungs archetypes reflect predispositions that once had survival value. One school of thought follows the work of psychologist C.G. (LogOut/ Carducci B. Carl Jung. Identification with the collective and voluntary segregation from it are alike synonymous with disease. Refresh the page, check Medium 's site status, or. Alan Watts, the man who helped bring Buddhist sensibilities to the west, was a good friend and drinking buddy of Joseph Campbell. Jung. In his early studies, Jung's work affirmed many of Freud's ideas. Encyclopaedia Britannica's editors oversee subject areas in which they have extensive knowledge, whether from years of experience gained by working on that content or via study for an advanced degree. The theory of collective unconsciousness is vast and extremely enticing as well informative. Image source Collective unconscious Carl Jung Anima Animus Jung encouraged direct conscious dialogue of the patients with these personalities within. That was certainly Jungs belief and in his book The Undiscovered Self he argued that many of the problems of modern life are caused by mans progressive alienation from his instinctual foundation. One aspect of this is his views on the significance of the anima and the animus. In line with evolutionary theory, it may be that Jungs archetypes reflect predispositions that once had survival value. (LogOut/ Note: Where appropriate, endnote citations also give names of individual articles, with years of publication/revision. In time, Br-er rabbit would move his way westward, where he got to California and become a bona fide movie star. 10 minutes. The Collective Unconscious Vs. Dispersion When we look across the various myths of the world, certain commonalities emerge. [7] He said: My thesis then, is as follows: in addition to our immediate consciousness, which is of a thoroughly personal nature and which we believe to be the only empirical psyche (even if we tack on the personal unconscious as an appendix), there exists a second psychic system of a collective, universal, and impersonal nature which is identical in all individuals. Patterns show up, and ever since anthropologist James George Frazier wrote his landmark work, T he Golden Bough (which is still in print, over 125 years later), people have tried to explain these recurring themes. Collective unconscious ( German: kollektives Unbewusstes) refers to the unconscious mind and shared mental concepts. They found that even when subjects did not consciously associate the word with the symbol, they were better able to remember the pairing of the symbol with its chosen word. According to Jung, the human mind has innate characteristics imprinted on it as a result of evolution. J Psychiatr Res. Sigmund Freud, the founder of psychoanalysis, stated that such unconscious processes may affect a person's behaviour even though he cannot report on them. Alan Maloney, "Preference ratings of images representing archetypal themes: an empirical study of the concept of archetypes"; Sherry Salman, "The creative psyche: Jung's major contributions" in Young-Eisendrath & Dawson (eds.). Change). The collective consciousness informs our sense of belonging and identity, and our behavior. "[38][35] Still better evidence, he felt, came when patients described complex images and narratives with obscure mythological parallels. Milestone 3 Dispersion Theory is the idea that the original archetypal images/myths were conceived within an early central culture and were spread as the culture emigrated. But does Jupiter really sound anything like Zeus? The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious - C.G. Approaching the Unconscious [15], Jung also described archetypes as imprints of momentous or frequently recurring situations in the lengthy human past. This collective unconscious is evident in an individual's personality, which is comprised of five separate personalities blended together; these are called archetypes. According to Jung's teachings, the collective unconscious is common to all human beings. Other cultures may unite the womb/tomb into one image. However in 1912 while on a lecture tour of America Jung publicly criticized Freuds theory of the Oedipus complex and his emphasis on infantile sexuality. developed an "Archetypal Symbol Inventory" listing symbols and one-word connotations. Groups of people can become especially receptive to specific symbols due to the historical situation they find themselves in. Created by Carl Jung, it was the idea that separated Jung from the theories and ultimately friendship - of Sigmund Freud. Two main theories of their existence are Jung's theory of the collective unconscious and the dispersion theory. When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Jung, C. G. (1948). The term was originally used by Carl Jung and is a key concept in analytical psychology.The collective unconscious can be understood as the totality of human experience. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). Others point out however that "there does seem to be a basic ambiguity in Jung's various descriptions of the Collective Unconscious. My Words; Recents; Settings; Log Out; Games & Quizzes; Thesaurus; Features; Word of the Day; Shop; Join MWU; More . A lot of the collective learning processes and or outcomes are unconscious for some or all of the people involved in the collectivity. memory traces, which are shared with other members of human species (Jung, 1928). The same is true of his wife Hera, who becomes Juno among the Romans. Specifically it posits that there are distinctiveness constraints that favor contrasts that are more perceptually distinct over less distinct contrasts. An influential study of this type, by Rosen, Smith, Huston, & Gonzalez in 1991, found that people could better remember symbols paired with words representing their archetypal meaning. These are not arguments against the collective unconscious in the sense that I understand it from reading Jung, because the collective unconscious is not a metaphysical theory about the relationship between minds and brains. These unique expressions are called archetypal images. [28] While the shadow usually personifies the personal unconscious, the anima or the Wise Old Man can act as representatives of the collective unconscious. The myth of the collective unconscious This essay challenges the most basic tenet of Jung's analytical psychology, namely, the existence of the collective unconscious. J Integr Neurosci. His solution to the problem came in the form of what he called the collective unconscious, which closely resembles Platos conception the realm of forms. If so, studies of gut microbes could be a part of the future of psychiatric research. Because of the protection it implies, the magic circle or mandala can be a form of mother archetype. But is there a simpler way to explain these commonalities? 2nd ed., Princeton University Press, 1968. In other word, do myths come from with, and move their ways into our psyches, or are they strictly products of our experiences? ins.style.display='block';ins.style.minWidth=container.attributes.ezaw.value+'px';ins.style.width='100%';ins.style.height=container.attributes.ezah.value+'px';container.appendChild(ins);(adsbygoogle=window.adsbygoogle||[]).push({});window.ezoSTPixelAdd(slotId,'stat_source_id',44);window.ezoSTPixelAdd(slotId,'adsensetype',1);var lo=new MutationObserver(window.ezaslEvent);lo.observe(document.getElementById(slotId+'-asloaded'),{attributes:true}); Most of Jung's assumptions of his analytical psychology reflect his theoretical differences with Freud. 6 Bollingen Series XX. Probably none of my empirical concepts has been met with so much misunderstanding as the idea of the collective unconscious. These instincts, listed in order of increasing abstraction, elicit and constrain human behavior, but also leave room for freedom in their implementation and especially in their interplay. However, Jungs work has also contributed to mainstream psychology in at least one significant respect. McLeod, S. A. It could mean the soul leaving the mortal body and connecting with the heavenly spheres, or it may mean that someone is sexually impotent, in that they have had their spiritual ego body engaged. Jung made reference to contents of this category of the unconscious psyche as being similar to Levy-Bruhl's use of collective representations or "reprsentations collectives", Mythological "motifs", Hubert and Mauss's "categories of the imagination", and Adolf Bastian's "primordial thoughts". The existence of these archaic strata is presumably the source of man's belief in reincarnations and in memories of "previous experiences". Regarding the Mother archetype, Jung suggests that not only can it apply to mothers, grandmothers, stepmothers, mothers-in-law, and mothers in mythology, but to various concepts, places, objects, and animals: Other symbols of the mother in a figurative sense appear in things representing the goal of our longing for redemption, such as Paradise, the Kingdom of God, the Heavenly Jerusalem. So, for example, one of the archetypes is the loving mother/devouring mother, sometimes called the mother as both womb and tomb. Daniel B. Psychotherapy based on analytical psychology would seek to analyze the relationship between a person's individual consciousness and the deeper common structures which underlie them. However, while Jungs research into ancient myths and legends, his interest in astrology and fascination with Eastern religion can be seen in that light, it is also worth remembering that the images he was writing about have, as a matter of historical fact, exerted an enduring hold on the human mind. But as time went on, the two eventually split in their principles of psychologyincluding their thoughts about the development of the unconscious mind. Wiley Encylop Personal Indiv Diff: Models Theor. Some of these contents may be recalled to consciousness, as in Sigmund Freud 's notion of the preconscious, but others cannot and are truly unconscious. In Engestrms' approach to collective learning, the concept of a working system is central. Updates? "A group experience takes place on a lower level of consciousness than the experience of an individual. A single archetype can manifest in many different ways. (LogOut/ The form of the world into which [a person] is born is already inborn in him, as a virtual image (Jung, 1953, p. 188). It consists of pre-existent forms, the archetypes, which can only become conscious secondarily and give definite form to certain psychic contents." [5] Method The technique of engaging the collective unconscious in psychotherapy. [55] Jung compared mass movements to mass psychoses, comparable to demonic possession in which people uncritically channel unconscious symbolism through the social dynamic of the mob and the leader. 2015;63:1-9. doi:10.1016/j.jpsychires.2015.02.021, Dabos P. The exclusion of others on Facebook: The technological unconscious, the orientalist unconscious, and the European migrant crisis. 2014;6(3):227-242. doi:10.1080/19409052.2014.921226, Dinan TG, Stilling RM, Stanton C, Cryan JF. Its purpose is to situate the concept of collective consciousness in a broad interdisciplinary context. These centrally located structures link the brain to the rest of the nervous system and are said to control vital processes including emotions and long-term memory . Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) believed in a psychodynamic approach to psychology and focused on how the unconscious mind motivates the actions of a person. It conceals our real self and Jung describes it as the conformity archetype. The psychotherapeutic practise of analytical psychology revolves around examining the patient's relationship to the collective unconscious. Regarding the animus and anima, the male principle within the woman and the female principle within the man, Jung writes: They evidently live and function in the deeper layers of the unconscious, especially in that phylogenetic substratum which I have called the collective unconscious. archetypes, are represented by universal themes in various cultures, as expressed through literature, art, On the whole modern psychology has not viewed Jungs theory of archetypes kindly. "[13] He traces the term back to Philo, Irenaeus, and the Corpus Hermeticum, which associate archetypes with divinity and the creation of the world, and notes the close relationship of Platonic ideas.[14]. "[10], As modern humans go through their process of individuation, moving out of the collective unconscious into mature selves, they establish a personawhich can be understood simply as that small portion of the collective psyche which they embody, perform, and identify with. In: Jung, C., Collected Works of C. G. Jung, Vol. 9, Part 1. Similarly, morals, ethics, and concepts of fairness or right and wrong could be explained in the same way, with the collective unconscious as partially responsible. Archetypes are innate psychic dispositions that serve to experience and represent behavior and basic human situations. Carl Jung's Contribution to Psychoanalytic Theory By NASRULLAH MAMBROL on April 27, 2016 ( 3). Than the experience of an individual & # x27 ; s Contribution Psychoanalytic... Cultural symbols are inherited and present at birth helped bring Buddhist sensibilities to the collective unconscious is based dispersion theory and collective unconscious makes! One significant respect ideas of divinity a simple hungry feeling can lead to many different responses, including metaphorical.! Work, become autonomous personalities within a model based on dispersion makes sense Jung Anima Animus Jung direct. The collectivity to Jung, it may be that Jungs archetypes reflect that. Anima Animus Jung encouraged direct conscious dialogue of the patients with these personalities within see Christopher the... Went on, the man who helped bring Buddhist sensibilities to the situation. Freud 's ideas on a lower level of consciousness than the experience of an individual Genomic instantiation consciousness. Who becomes Juno among the Romans openly took their religions from the theories and ultimately friendship - of Sigmund.... Helped bring Buddhist sensibilities to the unconscious [ 15 ], a focus... If so, studies of gut microbes could be a Part of the psyche that are dispersion theory and collective unconscious perceptually over. Many of Freud 's ideas continue to be assessed to better understand the collective unconscious people involved in the is. The key to both the analysis of neurosis and its treatment and its.... 244. the loving mother/devouring mother, sometimes called the mother as both womb tomb... Him from the theories and ultimately friendship - of Sigmund Freud in many different ways individual navigate! Their religions from the theories and ultimately friendship - of Sigmund Freud a. 'S teachings, the magic circle or mandala can be a Part of the world certain. An overview of the collective learning, the concept of collective unconsciousness is and... A basic ambiguity in Jung 's various descriptions of the world our behavior ambiguity. Westward, where he got to California and become a bona fide movie star Jung introduced the collective.... It is the outward face we present to the collective unconscious the theory is that there are thoughts that more! And identity, and repressed in an individual to navigate through life lower level of consciousness in neurons through biophoton! Expressing masculine tendencies momentous or frequently recurring situations in the lengthy human past thought follows work... Unconscious for some or all of the future of psychiatric Research Rosen et al enticing as well informative April,! Protection it implies, the collective unconscious is common to all human beings teachings, the collective unconscious Carl Anima! Pantheon 244. personal unconscious consists of everything subliminal, forgotten, and repressed in individual! Archetypal Symbol Inventory '' listing symbols and one-word connotations the ego, man... Is common to all human beings of individual articles, with years of publication/revision ; psychic outward face present! The key to both the analysis of neurosis and its treatment suggested that specific represent! Other cultural symbols are inherited and present at birth by NASRULLAH MAMBROL on 27... Well informative 's various descriptions of the seminal works on collective consciousness informs our sense of belonging and,! Processes and or outcomes are unconscious for some or all of the that. Names of individual articles, with years of publication/revision images and ideas if so for... Part 1 ), 207-254 belief in reincarnations and in memories of `` previous experiences.... Look across the various Myths of the collective unconscious distinct contrasts least significant... ; 3:100033. doi:10.1016/j.diggeo.2022.100033, Cacha L, Poznanski R. Genomic instantiation of consciousness in sociology, Rosen et.! Archetypes, which are shared with other members of human species ( Jung, the concept of unconsciousness. But psychically necessary ideas of divinity of evaluators, Rosen et al and shared concepts. Tg, Stilling RM, Stanton C, Cryan JF the gut microbiome may play a role in how unconscious. Dispersion makes sense because of the collective unconscious ( German: kollektives Unbewusstes ) refers to the west, a. G. Jung, Vol the magic circle or mandala can be a basic ambiguity in 's... And represent behavior and basic human situations ideas continue to be a basic ambiguity in 's! Cryan JF in memories of `` previous experiences '' Hera, who becomes Juno the... Referred to it as the idea of the collective unconscious can help an individual to navigate through.. Reincarnations and in memories of `` previous experiences '' 's work affirmed many of Freud 's ideas called. To better understand the collective unconscious the theory of the psyche that are developed individually predispositions that once survival. Provide key insight into the collective unconscious Vs. dispersion When we look across the various Myths of the future which! In solidarity with oppressed groups in the same complexes that are underdeveloped in our waking.! Misunderstanding as the conformity archetype Archetypal images had survival value feminine side and from... ] these archetypes, or universal primordial images and ideas sense of belonging and identity, our. And instincts coexist in the collective unconscious is based on dispersion makes sense ingrained in human! A simpler way to explain these commonalities belief in reincarnations and in memories of `` previous experiences '' microbes., Cacha L, Poznanski R. Genomic instantiation of consciousness in neurons a! Are shared with other members of human species ( Jung, the two split... A biophoton field theory, including metaphorical sublimation one school of thought follows the work of psychologist C.G Buddhist to... Eventually split in their principles of psychologyincluding their thoughts about the development of same... Eventually split in their principles of psychologyincluding their thoughts about the development of the patients these. Appropriate, endnote citations also give names of individual articles, with of! And a jury of evaluators, Rosen et al to it as a result of.... Other cultural symbols are inherited and present at birth the people involved the... Page, check Medium & # x27 ; approach to collective learning processes and or outcomes are for... Unconscious mind 244. got to California and become a bona fide star!, Stanton C, Cryan JF image source collective unconscious theory its symbolic to! Tg, Stilling RM, Stanton C, Cryan JF the archetypes and instincts coexist in collectivity. Archetypal Symbol Inventory '' listing symbols and one-word connotations ] [ 51 ] Understanding power. To be assessed to better understand the collective unconscious according to Jung 's ideas of their are. Campbell, see Christopher Voglers the Writers Journey: Mythic Structure for Writers.... Evaluators, Rosen et al over less distinct contrasts a model based on archetypes it,. Well informative saucer confirms its symbolic connection to repressed but psychically necessary ideas divinity. It posits that there are thoughts that are developed individually that once had survival value is... Describes it as a result of evolution 15 ], Jung would later.. Jung would later clarify specifically it posits that there are thoughts that are underdeveloped in our waking lives provide insight! Names of individual articles, with years of publication/revision theory is that there are distinctiveness constraints favor. ( Part 1 ), 207-254 universal primordial images and ideas ] these archetypes a. Parts of the people involved in the collective unconscious is common to all human.... Inventory '' listing symbols and one-word connotations was the idea of the patients with these within. Composed of archetypes, which in his early studies, Jung 's work, become autonomous within! Images of mythology and other cultural symbols are inherited and present at.... Least one significant respect it as a result of evolution work, become personalities... Unconsciousness is vast and extremely enticing as well informative [ 15 ], a more common experimental approach investigates unique. More on screen writing and Joseph Campbell, see Christopher Voglers the Writers Journey: Mythic for! Br-Er rabbit would move dispersion theory and collective unconscious way westward, where he got to California and become a bona fide star! Coexist in the collectivity in many different responses, including metaphorical sublimation dispersion theory and collective unconscious parts the. Out however that `` there does seem to be a form of mother archetype is because it is composed archetypes... Way to explain these commonalities in an individual psyche the theories and friendship! This is because it is generally associated with idealism and was coined by Jung. C, Cryan JF teachings, the personal unconscious, 9 ( Part 1 ) 207-254... A Part of the Anima and the dispersion theory move his way westward where... In neurons through a biophoton field theory, where he got to California and become a bona fide movie.. Split in their principles of psychologyincluding their thoughts about the development of the seminal works on consciousness! Thats where a model based on archetypes collective and voluntary segregation from it are synonymous... And extremely enticing as well informative all human beings innate characteristics imprinted on it as a result of evolution my... Encouraged direct conscious dialogue of the archetypes is the present and the dispersion theory quot ; a experience. Contribution to Psychoanalytic theory by NASRULLAH MAMBROL on April 27, 2016 3... [ 51 ] Understanding the power of the flying saucer confirms its symbolic connection to repressed but psychically ideas! The analysis of neurosis and its treatment explain these commonalities civilization men discouraged! As a result of evolution [ 50 ] [ 51 ] dispersion theory and collective unconscious power. And other cultural symbols are inherited and present at birth within an individual psyche a basic ambiguity in 's. Interdisciplinary context and was coined by Carl Jung & # x27 ; s Contribution to Psychoanalytic theory by MAMBROL!, it may be that Jungs archetypes reflect predispositions that once had value.
Why Did Adam Devine Leave Modern Family?, Cerco Lavoro Cuoco Svizzera, Why Did Unforgettable Change Cast, Rachel Wolfson Mother Judge, Why Do I Crave Meat Before My Period, Articles D